Sunday, February 26, 2012

She ends up with HIM?!

Have you ever noticed that the author sometimes picks the wrong guy? I have. As a matter of fact it happens quite frequently. I feel badly for these authors, it must be embarrassing for them to one day realize they picked the wrong boy. In case they haven't realized yet, I'm here to call them out on it. Here are my top 5 "She ends up with him??!!"'s:

5. Eliza Doolittle and Henry Higgins?

Really? He is a grumpy old man. (Did you notice his pinky ring? I did.) Why George Bernard Shaw, why? He's not very nice to her. Ever. Also, what about Freddy? Yes his name is Freddy, but that's better than Henry Higgins. He adores Eliza. He writes her twice a day sometimes sheets and sheets. Sure he's poor, but he's king enough for her. Also, he sings out on her street. He can sing on my street anytime.
So I guess I can almost understand why Eliza doesn't pick Freddy, but couldn't the movie have a better ending? Like maybe Higgins could say something sweet to Eliza instead of "Where the devil are my slippers?" Some cute line might make me change my mind.

4. Christine and Raoul?

Okay I know some people are going to hate me for this, but every time I watch this movie or play I'm a little sad that Christine doesn't end up with the Phantom.
Sure he's kind of evil and creepy. He may be a murderer and a bit possessive, but I still cheer him on. Why? I blame Raoul's wig and Andrew Lloyd Weber for giving the Phantom better songs.

3. Mr. Collins & Charlotte Lucas?

Oh Jane Austen, you have made this world a better place. I really like most of your matches. I mean, is there anything cuter than Bingley and Jane or Emma and Mr Knightley? No there is not. Your matches are usually so perfect for each other, but there is one you really screwed up. Mr Collins and Charlotte Lucas? Really?! I don't care if she says she's quite content in her situation. Not buying it. You know who would have been really content in that situation? Mary Bennett, or Mary Collins. (Skip to 4:30 on this clip) I like the sound of that. This way Charlotte Lucas' character could stay reasonable, Mary Bennett wouldn't live her life out as an old maid, and Mr Collins would have a wife who actually respects, maybe even adores him. Plus, look at that picture - don't they make a lovely pair?
Oh did I fail to mention that Mrs. Bennett can live her life in comfort knowing that she won't be turned out of her house by Charlotte Lucas? Win. Win. Win.

2. Katniss and Peeta?

I am a huge Hunger Games fan. I can't wait for the movie to come out, but I'm going to be honest - I'm Team Gale. I fell in love with him in the first chapter and I'm still cheering him on. I'm hoping Suzanne Collins writes a fourth book where there's another Hunger Games. Peeta will enter and die and then Katniss and Gale can live happily ever after. Just kidding, but not really. At least she could re-write the last one and not completely change Gale's character!
Maybe I didn't give Peeta a fair chance because every time he had a cute scene I wanted it to be Gale instead. I was about to re-read the books and try and open my heart to Peeta when these movie posters came out. That's when I knew I would always be Team Gale.

1. Jo and Fox, or Bear?

The worst offender for messing up a good couple and making a rotten one goes to Louisa May Alcott. Congratulations Louisa, your couple makes me the angriest. Let's talk for a second about Jo and Laurie. They are perfect for each other. They quarrel all the time, but they are best friends. They get into all sorts of mischief together, but they help each other.They fit perfectly into one another's families and they are just perfect. Let's talk about Bear and Jo. Um, he's her grandpa. Not really, but he could be.
He's super old and boring. Jo is a fascinating character full of life and adventures, she doesn't want someone who is old, wrinkled, lined and flabby. Sure Laurie will get old, wrinkled, lined, and flabby, but not by next week. Also, Laurie and Amy?! How awkward would you feel if a boy who proposed to you and was way in love with you became your brother in law? Or you knew your husband used to be way in love with your sister? Awkward.

I've included pictures from both the old and "new" Little Women. I grew up with both of these movies and I thought the Bear was just as bothersome in both and Laurie was just as cute.
I've been bugged about this ending since I was eight. Go ahead and try to reason with me, but it won't do. Jo and Laurie were supposed to be together and for some bizarre reason
Louisa tore them apart and put them with incompatible people. Not okay. One time I had a dream Laurie and Jo ended up together, I think I'm going to pretend that's real life.

So what about you? Which book, or movie, made you think, "She ends up with HIM?!"

P.S. Click on the bold words for videos.

4 comments:

  1. Okay, thank you for posting all the clips along with the movies you mentioned. I agree with all of yours except Phantom. I was always so sad for him, but I would have been more sad for Raoul. :( Also, I quite like Peeta (although either one she got together with, you would feel SO sad for the other!) And you totally put the #1 choice in the perfect spot! I remember how devastated I was the first time I finished Little Women and realized she really wasn't going to make up with and marry Laurie! That was a sad day...

    ReplyDelete
  2. -I love Freddy. He's so handsome and I love that song. But did I tell you about when I saw this as a play and the guy playing Henry Higgins was super attractive so I liked the ending?
    -Um, the phantom is gross and creepy. But so is Rauol so ...whatever.
    -That picture of Collins and Mary is genius.
    -She didn't change Gale's character. He loves Katniss, but he is also so focused on over running the capitol and everything Peeta does is for Katniss and I'm serious---read them again and you might feel better. I still love Gale, but I like how she ended it.
    -Gross. Little Women is the all time worst. That first picture of Laurie is so great.
    -Finally: Renesmee and Jacob? She ends up with him? That's nasty.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Don't agree with you on Phantom. I think Raoul is so sweet! Hate Henry Higgins and HATE HATE HATE that Jo doesn't end up with Laurie. I don't usually finish Little Women anymore because it is so upsetting to me!

    ReplyDelete
  4. 5- Totally agree.
    4- You're weird, Phantom is way creepy. But your mention of Raoul's wig totally made me laugh.
    3- They kind of work for each other because they're both quite annoying, but yeah, Mary would be a better match! (Love the picture)
    2- Well I haven't read the 3rd book yet...you ruined it! Jk. I've really liked Peeta so far though; but the Gale in the movie just might change my mind.
    1- Yes yes yes. Stupid Jo for not going for her best friend.

    ReplyDelete